McGahee. Barber has been doing great, but against a tough D in Tampa. McGahee is facing an Oakland team with a new coach and meager defense.In Week 8, should I start Marion Barber against Tampa or Willis Mcgahee against Oakland?
You have to stick with Barber. McGahee may have looked good on Sunday, but Miami couldnt tackle anyone in that game. Also, he's still running with a lot of pain in his knee and he could re-injure it during the game. Barber on the other hand is healthy, will get a lot of opportunities to run with Romo out. MB will catch a lot of passes out the backfield in this game too, if receptions help you in your league.
Good LuckIn Week 8, should I start Marion Barber against Tampa or Willis Mcgahee against Oakland?
McGahee.
Dallas is in the middle of what could be their hardest stretch of the season. Tampa's D is in the top 10 against the run. Though Barber is their best offensive player, he's averaging less than 80 yards a game.
McGahee has been effective and productive the last 2 weeks. Oakland ranks 24th against the run. Playing at home should be a plus, as Joe Flacco will look to manage the game by handing it off to open up the passing game.
I would start McGahee. The Jets ran for over 230 yards against the Raiders last week. Barber is a great back but Tampa has a good D and Brad Johnson will start again this week. Tampa will make Brad beat them with his arm and judging by the way T.O has played lately, it will not happen
